1The 50% Rule
If a single repair costs more than 50% of the car's value, replacement usually makes more sense. But consider it over a year—$3,000 in repairs over 12 months might still be cheaper than a car payment.
2Consider Annual Costs
Add up repair costs over the past year. If you're spending more than you would on a reasonable used car payment, it might be time to switch.
3The Cascade Problem
When one major system fails, others often follow. If you just replaced the transmission and now the engine needs work, you're pouring money into a failing vehicle.
4Factors Beyond Cost
Consider reliability for your situation.
- Do you need the car for work?
- Can you afford to be stranded?
- Do you have AAA/CAA coverage?
- Is the car still safe?
Key Takeaways
- 150% rule for single repairs
- 2Track annual repair costs
- 3Multiple major failures = time to move on
- 4Reliability matters for work vehicles
Need personalized help?
Connect with a certified mechanic who can answer questions specific to your vehicle.
Ask a Mechanic